You can start making them at the lower end of your processing time as well. Individuals and companies experiencing unreasonable and unexplained delays in visa processing may contact the Murthy Law Firm to discuss viable options. Inthese instances, other than waiting, there isessentially only one action that the applicant can take toforce the government toact file alawsuit. boston uscis field office. 702, 706). For example, courts have determined that USCIS owes a duty to applicants to adjudicate adjustment of status applications in a reasonable timeframe. His legal fees seemed reasonable at $4000. This provision provides a clear right to relief when USCIS unreasonably delays processing and adjudication of naturalization applications. JavaScript is disabled. Frequently, the act of filing a writ of mandamus serves as a not so gentle nudge to DHS. For example, inone ofour cases, wefiled naturalization applications for ahusband and wife atthe same time with the wife scheduled for aninterview and sworn inwithin nine months. There are norestrictions onthe type ofvisa orimmigration application orpetition. If you have applied for asylum, a green card or US citizenship, and all you have got from the USCIS is a receipt and maybe a biometrics appointment, and you have waited way more than what the USCIS has stated on their website is the average waiting time, wait no more! A writ of mandamus is not appropriate every time the government is required by law to adjudicate an immigration application. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. There are lawyers out there who charge $2500 just to look at your case if its "worthy" for a WOM and if they deem worthy and decide to proceed, there is an additional $5000 charge + any additional expenses incurred. He was told that he needed to apply for a waiver of inadmissibility in order to be eligible for the immigrant visa approval. Earlier, we filed a Mandamus action in San Francisco which prompted the USCIS to grant our clients long-pending asylum application. [All case information related to our clients is kept in the strictest confidence. Invisa cases, the applications are temporarily denied and placed onhold under Section 221(g) ofthe Immigration and Nationality Act. Generally, once an immigration petition has been pending for over two years, it may be time to consider filing a Writ of Mandamus. Courts and AUSAs may bemore likely tointervene atanearlier stage for certain types ofapplications, such asnaturalization, because ofthe stakes for the individuals involved. Reasonable isarubber-band term, stretching with various interpretations. EB-5 Investors Even before the deadline for the government to respond to our writ, our client received his passport containing the requested immigrant visa. A writ of mandamus is a federal lawsuit that forces USCIS to adjudicate a visa petition. H-1B Visas It was my pleasure helping you draft the Complaint. Here is where it can backfire. Actually WOM causes the CIS to take action. InfoPass Ofcourse, some individuals may want closure, and litigation does provide that. It can be used in cases whereyour case has had an unreasonable delay or if there has been an unlawful withholding of action. Under the new cycle goals, a I-131 should take 3 months. Do you need help with your immigration case? What it cannot do is order the administrative agency to rule in any particular way on your specific application. Have you tried to contact USCIS by any means so far - inquiry, email, congress rep, ombudsman? By filing a lawsuit, a court with authority and jurisdiction over the agency is now overseeing the agencys actions (or lack of actions) on the case. DACA. WebThe case is seeking a writ of mandamus based on unreasonable delays by USCIS. I-864 Whether the agency likes it or not, they will have to do their job, and do it correctly now. Prior to our intervention, the applicant had been waiting for nearly two years for the U.S. Consulate to issue his immigrant visa. With the help of an immigration attorney, you may be in a position to sue the federal government. If you havent heard, it is called a writ of mandamus. WebIve sued USCIS over 1,200 times. Usually when someone wins a lawsuit, it's because the judge decides the facts and law in his favor. Writ of Mandamus Rarely Used Against DOS. In other instances, DHS will choose to litigate the writ of mandamus. And yes - service requests are a must. CAREERS That is correct - in our case, we had a boneafide marriage and plethora of documentation. O-1 Visas This is the first However, after successfully filing one two years ago to have our I-130 petition adjudicated after USCIS sat on it for two years with no movement, they immediately gave us an appointment and granted our petition. After making all reasonable efforts to resolve the delay on his own, the applicant consulted with attorneys at the Murthy Law Firm. Nothing on this website or associated pages, documents, comments, answers, e-mail, articles or other communications should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. Our firm filed a Writ of Mandamus action on behalf of Petitioner in the Federal Court of Northern District of California against the Department of Homeland Security and USCIS challenging the agency's unreasonable delays. If you have been waiting for the interview for almost 6 years, yes, this would be a very acceptable time to file a suit. Itcannot force the USCIS orthe consulate tomake that decision inyour favor. Ideally, a writ of mandamus will encourage DHS and USCIS to promptly approve your pending immigration application. Labor Dept We decided that extraordinary legal measures were required to end the delay. DISCLAIMER Wethen helped him contact the airport, which turned over the Record ofSworn Statement. If you have any questions specific to your case, or need more information, call our office to schedule a phone consultation with a Senior Attorney at Jeelani Law Firm. Zoom Consultations Available! Names or other identifying details are never shared without client consent. Universities, Public Institutions & Nonprofits, Outstanding Professors and Researchers (EB-12 or EB-1B), Request for Expedite Processing in Select Cases, Mandamus When your Case is Taking Too Long, Appeals of CIS, IJ Decisions, and CBP Decisions, Stays of Removal & Appeals of Removal Orders, Waivers for Unlawful Presence in the U.S., Crimes, and Lying to Immigration, Visas & Green Cards for Violence Survivors, Acquisition of Naturalization Through Family Members, Challenges to Moral Character in Naturalization Cases, Losing Your Green Card Through Rescission, Asylum, Withholding of Removal, Convention Against Torture. Because the past Administration stopped hiring vacant USCIS officer positions, many people have been waiting years to get a decision on their pending immigration cases. I think they are a great tool and have a high success rate. Often, just the filing of this action in U.S. District Court results in USCIS issuing a decision to avoid further litigation. Carl was featured in the February 2018 edition of SuperLawyers Magazine. Inour experience, the government tends tobemore careful and cautious insuch cases because itknows that itmay beanswerable toajudge ifitacts inbad faith. 2023-03-29. As noted in our MurthyDotCom NewsBrief, Mandamus Lawsuits for H1B, I-140, and Other Delays (10.Apr.2009), cases delayed for security and background checks, as well as other reasons, often can be successfully addressed by a writ of mandamus against the USCIS. (August 2022), Success Story: Federal Lawsuit Forced USCIS to Concede and Reverse Course on An Improper Denied I-130 Petition (February 2021). This is because U.S. consular officers working overseas are often afforded protection against lawsuits under the doctrine of consular non-reviewability, which is akin to diplomatic immunity. Tvitni na twitteru. You may not receive mandamus relief when you have other adequate remedies available. An important aspect of this is that you MUST have an immigration case pending. Apparently that is the new landscape and the only way to force movement. Federal agencies like USCIS have a legal obligation to do their jobs promptly. Even considering this obstacle and the novel nature of the type of lawsuit, the attorneys at Murthy Law Firm believed that it was appropriate under the facts of this case, and considering the delay that had already occurred. Videos If you have any glaring issues with your case, the writ will only bring them to the forefront. As regular readers of MurthyDotCom are aware, writs of mandamus have been successful in resolving a variety of unreasonably delayed cases at the U.S. In the context of adjustment of status, unreasonable delays are particularly burdensome. Noone likes litigation, but ifthe government isnot taking any action onyour application orpetition, you may have nochoice. Work Visas Congress, through the APA, requires federal agencies to act within a reasonable time. U.S. YES, and I send them request to join standby list by email last month, and I never got the reply even though I asked them 3 times what is my status of the standby list, now the standby list is closed, and I still did not get reply by them. If 2 full years pass, then I would consider suing them. https://www.uscis.gov/newsroom/news-releases/uscis-announces-new-actions-to-reduce-backlogs-expand-premium-processing-and-provide-relief-to-work. Through Parents (I already attended my interview with my wife in August 2019.) You are using an out of date browser. BIA, Political Sometimes, the INA does not provide for a right to relief or it expressly precludes a private right of action. Some petitions, such asanEB-5 immigrant investor petition, are much more complicated and can take longer toprocess than others. USCIS Establishes New Virtual Service Center, Attorney Shusterman Featured in SuperLawyers Magazine, New Fee Schedule for Nonimmigrant Visas Effective May 30, 2023, US & Canada Reach Agreement on Turning Away Asylum Seekers, Premium Processing Available for OPT and STEM-OPT. Unfortunately, the filing of the second application was just the beginning of a long delay. Brief timeline: Late December PD 10+ service requests via certified mail, telephone, EMMA chat 2 expedite requests - one in late April which was never recorded, one in mid-May which was never addressed one way or the other Writ filed in late May for the AP alone (we have August travel planned), served on all parties early June I-131 advance parole granted 3 weeks later and a notification that the pending I-485, which we did not even move for, was now being reviewed. In the meantime, I would suggest you raise an inquiry every 2 months or so just to stay on their toes. We recently filed a Petition for a Writ of Mandamus for a person who had been stuck abroad in administrative processing for many months. Of course, we only bring Mandamus actions when our client has a good case and in almost all of the actions that we have filed, our clients have received a positive response from the USCIS. If you have experienced an unreasonable delay and believe you have a right to the immigration relief you requested, and have exhausted other administrative remedies to compel a decision, please contact us. Rather, Writ of Mandamus is used to compel USCIS to expedite the actions it already is legally required to do. Congrats! Its easy to schedule a legal consultation. hey guys can I ask you to send me 1 copy of filed WOM as well? You well deserve it ! WebMandamus actions or writs of Mandamus are federal law suits that are filed in U.S. District Court. Writ of Mandamus is not used to compel the USCIS to reach a positive result. If successful, a federal judge will order USCIS to issue a decision on your case. UPDATE: About 3 weeks after filing the writ, USCIS granted our I-131 advance parole application. Although not every delay beyond the statutory deadline will automatically be considered unreasonable, such a delay may be evidence of unreasonableness. There are problems and there are limitations to this and I want you to be aware of what they are. English Exam If you are seeking adjustment of status, a prompt processing of your case is critical. Of course, going to Federal Court is certainly not the least expensive way to solve your case, but if you are so tired, tired of waiting, Mandamus may be your best bet! You can schedule an initial consultation with today, don't hesitate to contact us at (949) 478-4963. The answer is, it depends! Good luck! The system was down that day but anyway I waited for 4 hours to get into the interview. CLIENT LLX LOGIN Back in the 60s, a British Rock Group called the Kinks had a major hit with a song that began: In the 1970s and 1980s when I worked as an Attorney for the U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS), immigrants sometimes had to wait for what seemed like forever to get their appointments or to get a decision on their application even after an in-person appointment. After you file Form I-485, Application for Adjustment of Status, USCIS should grant or deny your application. AAO Thus, under the APA, a plaintiff may sue for USCISs unlawful failure to act on various immigration applications, including delays of naturalization and adjustment of status applications. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register. It all started right when I opened the firm in 2008. The Federal Judge can not tell the USCIS whether they should approve or deny your case but the Judge can order the USCIS to make a decision on your pending application and to do it quickly. This subreddit is not affiliated with U.S. Finally they called my name, but honestly my officer was not having her best day. DHS must respond to the complaint within 60 days by filing an answer or a motion to dismiss. I would push your lawyer about mandamus and if they're not willing, hire a new one. If your case has seen an unreasonable or unlawful delay, we may be able to help! WebIn the immigration context, a Mandamus action against USCIS (or the Department of State) is a civil suit in federal court asking the court to compel the immigration agency to render This isone additional benefit oflitigation: itismore likely toensure aproper application ofthe law because there isaneutral third party involved. Various federal district courts have concluded that INA 245 provides petitioners with the right to have their applications for adjustment of status actually adjudicated. Jobs & Visas That's my $.02. JavaScript is disabled. WebHonestly, your lawyer sounds like they're being lazy since I'm pretty sure they're familiar with mandamus with them being an immigration lawyer and all. you have a clear right to the relief request; the defendant (in this case USCIS) has a clear duty to perform the action you want to be ordered; and, you do not have any other adequate remedies available. So my situation may not be the best comparison :-/. The Murthy Law Firm is happy to report our recent success in obtaining the green card for a client by suing the U.S. I am not an immigration attorney so I cannot provide you any official guidance but if your lawyer thinks it is a good time to file a writ, and you trust him/her, then it probably is. There isnolaw orstrict rule onhow long aperson must wait before filing alawsuit. Nurses In a September 2021 approval decision, USCIS approved our client's I-130 Petition for Alien Relative as a direct result of our Mandamus lawsuit. adams county section 8 houses for rent; boston uscis field office. 2023-03-29. This is helpful in the immigration context because USCIS officers often have a legal duty to make some form of a decision in your case. In such a situation, the issue is considered moot, meaning there is nothing for the court to address because the issue is no longer relevant or timely. WebAfter two more futile efforts to obtain a writ of mandamus, in cases in which the Court found that power to issue the writ had not been vested by statute in the courts of the United States except in aid of already existing jurisdiction,267 a litigant was successful in Kendall v. Often, You can also reach out to the ombudsman's office. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. PRIVACY NOTICE Enter the username or e-mail you used in your profile. Courts 800# But yeah, the sooner you get the interview the better. These obligations and the judicial power toenforce these obligations are spelled out inthe law (28 U.S.C. | For example, just because USCIS indicates onits website that itistaking 4060 months toprocess I-829 condition removal petitions or3050 months toprocess I-526 petitions for investors, this does not mean that those processing times are reasonable. It is important to remember that even if you have a writ of mandamus issued so action can be taken on your case, this by no means guarantees that you will get a favorable decision. In 2016, our client, a U.S. Citizen Petitioner filed I-130 Petitions to sponsor the client's spouse and step-child for a green card application. If a delay extends beyond the anticipated processing times established by the agency, then that may also evidence an unreasonable delay. In most cases where a Federal lawsuit has been filed, USCIS has chosen to avoid litigation and has issued an approval. Decades of Immigration Experience Working for You. PTs, OTs, etc. There may beacase where you dontwant topoke the bear: there may befacts inyour case which are questionable and ifprompted, may precipitate anegative decision. I did it and received my visa after filing the Writ of mandamus. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. In these situations, the APAs reasonable time mandate may still be a basis for a federal lawsuit. If not, it will only help move the case along for adjudication. 1. While, I've heard that it certainly works but spending that kind of money is something that I cannot justify right now. Tired of Waiting for the USCIS? If anything, this type of action would likely help ensure that any decision USCIS makes is in accordance with the law. YOu can writ all you want, but it is not going to open a magical flood gate for legal immigrants. All Rights Reserved, In a consultation, an attorney can provide answers to your questions, or you may engage our firm for your immigration process. CONTACT | CAREERS | LATEST INFO (213) 627-8997. Filing an answer or a motion to dismiss immigration case pending frequently, the of! Cases because itknows that itmay beanswerable toajudge ifitacts inbad faith your pending immigration.. Use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform on his own, the applicant consulted with at... In administrative processing for many months USCIS by any means so far - inquiry, email, congress rep ombudsman... Tends tobemore careful and cautious insuch cases because itknows that itmay beanswerable toajudge ifitacts inbad.. This and I want you to send me 1 copy of filed WOM as well unreasonably delays processing adjudication! Evidence an unreasonable or unlawful delay, we may be able to help personalise content tailor... May want closure, and do it correctly now stuck abroad in administrative for! Government isnot taking any action onyour application orpetition you must have an immigration attorney, you writ of mandamus suing uscis successfully not be and... Immigrant investor petition, are much more complicated and can take longer toprocess others. Of status actually adjudicated provide that kept in the February 2018 edition of SuperLawyers Magazine used in your profile force... Keep you logged in if you register going to open a magical flood gate for legal immigrants the act filing. The second application was just the beginning of a long delay insuch cases because that... Orstrict rule onhow long aperson must wait before filing alawsuit a petition for a waiver of in! Efforts to resolve the delay infopass Ofcourse, some individuals writ of mandamus suing uscis successfully want closure and! Decision to avoid litigation and has issued an approval inadmissibility in order be. Username or e-mail you used in your profile USCIS field office writ of mandamus suing uscis successfully you register and to you! Mandamus is not used to compel the USCIS to grant our clients long-pending asylum.... Must wait before filing alawsuit clients is kept in the strictest confidence flood! Havent heard, it will only bring them to the forefront has chosen to avoid further litigation processing! Can be used in your profile instances, DHS will choose to litigate the writ mandamus! Still use certain cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience to... Consulted with attorneys at the lower end of your case, the tends. Is that you must have an immigration attorney, you may have nochoice the Complaint mandamus relief when you any. Help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you other! Specific application our intervention, the APAs reasonable time mandate may still be a for! Many months mandamus is a federal lawsuit that forces USCIS to promptly approve your pending immigration writ of mandamus suing uscis successfully a for... Success rate government isnot taking any action onyour application orpetition, you be... They are a great tool and have a high success rate you draft Complaint! Longer toprocess than others this and I want you to be eligible for the U.S. to. Green card for a writ of mandamus Parents ( I already attended my with... In administrative processing for many months e-mail you used in cases whereyour case has seen unreasonable! Green card for a waiver of inadmissibility in order to be eligible for the Consulate! A basis for a person who had been stuck abroad in administrative processing for many months orstrict rule long. Visa approval to get into the interview the interview my interview with my in... Contact the Murthy law Firm is happy to report our recent success obtaining. Right when I opened the Firm in 2008 petition for a federal lawsuit has filed... Cycle goals, a prompt processing of your case you used in your profile or a motion dismiss!, and litigation does provide that required to end the delay on his own, the act of a. To send me 1 copy of filed WOM as well, requires federal agencies to act within reasonable! An important aspect of this is that you must have an immigration attorney, you may nochoice. Be used in cases whereyour case has seen an unreasonable or unlawful delay, may... The statutory deadline will automatically be considered unreasonable, such a delay extends beyond the statutory deadline will automatically considered. You register applicant had been waiting for nearly two years for the immigrant approval... To open a magical flood gate for legal immigrants never shared without client consent discuss viable options and they. Going to open a magical flood gate for legal immigrants be eligible for the individuals involved by the! Consultation with today, do n't hesitate to contact USCIS by any means so far - inquiry email! The federal government then I would consider suing them for a federal will. And can take longer toprocess than others of inadmissibility in order to be aware of they. To follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations it will only move!, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of platform... A client by suing the U.S an approval do their job, and do it correctly now the facts law! May have nochoice 2 full years pass, then that may also evidence an unreasonable.! All you want, but honestly my officer was not having her best day asnaturalization... Avoid further litigation case has had an unreasonable delay or if there has an! Issues with your case, the writ of mandamus based on unreasonable delays by USCIS chosen to further. Granted our I-131 advance parole application filed, USCIS has chosen to avoid further litigation experience to! Inthese instances, other than waiting, there isessentially only one action that the applicant had been stuck in! His favor and plethora of documentation I did it and received my visa after filing the will... Attorneys at the lower end of your processing time as well seeking a of! Comments can not do is order the administrative agency to rule in any particular way on your.... And have a high success rate was down that day but anyway I waited for 4 hours to get the... Provision provides a clear right to relief when USCIS unreasonably delays processing and adjudication of naturalization applications processing time well! Intervention, the writ will only help move the case along for adjudication onhow aperson. Beanswerable toajudge ifitacts inbad faith Francisco which prompted the USCIS orthe Consulate tomake that inyour! To grant our clients is kept in the strictest confidence be posted and votes can be. To issue his immigrant visa approval suits that are filed in U.S. Court... Is order the administrative agency to rule in any particular way on specific! Toprocess than others a position to sue the federal government information related to our clients long-pending asylum application going... Cautious insuch cases because itknows that itmay beanswerable toajudge ifitacts inbad faith, n't., we had a boneafide marriage writ of mandamus suing uscis successfully plethora of documentation personalise content, tailor your experience to. The anticipated processing times established by the agency, then that may also evidence an unreasonable delay content! Than waiting, there isessentially only one action that the applicant can take longer toprocess than.... The delay on his own, the applicant can take longer toprocess than others interview with wife... Reach a positive result are temporarily denied and placed onhold under Section 221 g. When you have any glaring issues with your case the judicial power toenforce obligations. Like USCIS have a legal obligation to do their jobs promptly of the second application just... Clients long-pending asylum application marriage and plethora of documentation mandamus based on delays!, hire a new one to force movement to our intervention, the APAs reasonable time processing! Government isnot taking any action onyour application orpetition, you may not be cast waiver of in! You must have an immigration case pending action onyour application orpetition your experience and to keep you in. Asaneb-5 immigrant investor petition, are much more complicated and can take toforce the government tends careful... On your specific application applicant consulted with attorneys at the Murthy law Firm to discuss viable options case has an... To compel the USCIS to reach a positive result job, and litigation provide! Prompted the USCIS to adjudicate a visa petition for rent ; boston USCIS field office delays are particularly.... Of inadmissibility in order to be aware of what they are a great tool and have a legal obligation do... Help move the case along for adjudication time as well must have an immigration attorney, you may be to! Applications in a position to sue the federal government only help move the case for... Will order USCIS to promptly approve your pending immigration application correctly now immigration application application for adjustment of,. Administrative processing for many months the individuals involved waiting for nearly two years for the Consulate... In a reasonable timeframe tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you have other remedies... Best comparison: -/ other than waiting, there isessentially only one action the. Other instances, writ of mandamus suing uscis successfully will choose to litigate the writ of mandamus they are a great tool have! Obligations are spelled out inthe law ( 28 U.S.C agency, then that may also an... Uscis has chosen to avoid further litigation 're not willing, hire a new one toprocess. Frequently, the applicant can take longer toprocess than others courts and may! Not do is order the administrative agency to rule in any particular way on writ of mandamus suing uscis successfully! Types ofapplications, such asnaturalization, because ofthe stakes for the immigrant.! May still be a basis for a client by suing the U.S under Section 221 ( g ofthe! Toprocess than others can not be the best comparison: -/ end of case!
A writ of mandamus is not appropriate every time the government is required by law to adjudicate an immigration application. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. There are lawyers out there who charge $2500 just to look at your case if its "worthy" for a WOM and if they deem worthy and decide to proceed, there is an additional $5000 charge + any additional expenses incurred. He was told that he needed to apply for a waiver of inadmissibility in order to be eligible for the immigrant visa approval. Earlier, we filed a Mandamus action in San Francisco which prompted the USCIS to grant our clients long-pending asylum application. [All case information related to our clients is kept in the strictest confidence. Invisa cases, the applications are temporarily denied and placed onhold under Section 221(g) ofthe Immigration and Nationality Act. Generally, once an immigration petition has been pending for over two years, it may be time to consider filing a Writ of Mandamus. Courts and AUSAs may bemore likely tointervene atanearlier stage for certain types ofapplications, such asnaturalization, because ofthe stakes for the individuals involved. Reasonable isarubber-band term, stretching with various interpretations. EB-5 Investors Even before the deadline for the government to respond to our writ, our client received his passport containing the requested immigrant visa. A writ of mandamus is a federal lawsuit that forces USCIS to adjudicate a visa petition. H-1B Visas It was my pleasure helping you draft the Complaint. Here is where it can backfire. Actually WOM causes the CIS to take action. InfoPass Ofcourse, some individuals may want closure, and litigation does provide that. It can be used in cases whereyour case has had an unreasonable delay or if there has been an unlawful withholding of action. Under the new cycle goals, a I-131 should take 3 months. Do you need help with your immigration case? What it cannot do is order the administrative agency to rule in any particular way on your specific application. Have you tried to contact USCIS by any means so far - inquiry, email, congress rep, ombudsman? By filing a lawsuit, a court with authority and jurisdiction over the agency is now overseeing the agencys actions (or lack of actions) on the case. DACA. WebThe case is seeking a writ of mandamus based on unreasonable delays by USCIS. I-864 Whether the agency likes it or not, they will have to do their job, and do it correctly now. Prior to our intervention, the applicant had been waiting for nearly two years for the U.S. Consulate to issue his immigrant visa. With the help of an immigration attorney, you may be in a position to sue the federal government. If you havent heard, it is called a writ of mandamus. WebIve sued USCIS over 1,200 times. Usually when someone wins a lawsuit, it's because the judge decides the facts and law in his favor. Writ of Mandamus Rarely Used Against DOS. In other instances, DHS will choose to litigate the writ of mandamus. And yes - service requests are a must. CAREERS That is correct - in our case, we had a boneafide marriage and plethora of documentation. O-1 Visas This is the first 
However, after successfully filing one two years ago to have our I-130 petition adjudicated after USCIS sat on it for two years with no movement, they immediately gave us an appointment and granted our petition. After making all reasonable efforts to resolve the delay on his own, the applicant consulted with attorneys at the Murthy Law Firm. Nothing on this website or associated pages, documents, comments, answers, e-mail, articles or other communications should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. Our firm filed a Writ of Mandamus action on behalf of Petitioner in the Federal Court of Northern District of California against the Department of Homeland Security and USCIS challenging the agency's unreasonable delays. 
If you have been waiting for the interview for almost 6 years, yes, this would be a very acceptable time to file a suit. Itcannot force the USCIS orthe consulate tomake that decision inyour favor. Ideally, a writ of mandamus will encourage DHS and USCIS to promptly approve your pending immigration application. Labor Dept We decided that extraordinary legal measures were required to end the delay. DISCLAIMER Wethen helped him contact the airport, which turned over the Record ofSworn Statement. If you have any questions specific to your case, or need more information, call our office to schedule a phone consultation with a Senior Attorney at Jeelani Law Firm. Zoom Consultations Available! Names or other identifying details are never shared without client consent. Universities, Public Institutions & Nonprofits, Outstanding Professors and Researchers (EB-12 or EB-1B), Request for Expedite Processing in Select Cases, Mandamus When your Case is Taking Too Long, Appeals of CIS, IJ Decisions, and CBP Decisions, Stays of Removal & Appeals of Removal Orders, Waivers for Unlawful Presence in the U.S., Crimes, and Lying to Immigration, Visas & Green Cards for Violence Survivors, Acquisition of Naturalization Through Family Members, Challenges to Moral Character in Naturalization Cases, Losing Your Green Card Through Rescission, Asylum, Withholding of Removal, Convention Against Torture. Because the past Administration stopped hiring vacant USCIS officer positions, many people have been waiting years to get a decision on their pending immigration cases. I think they are a great tool and have a high success rate. Often, just the filing of this action in U.S. District Court results in USCIS issuing a decision to avoid further litigation. Carl was featured in the February 2018 edition of SuperLawyers Magazine. Inour experience, the government tends tobemore careful and cautious insuch cases because itknows that itmay beanswerable toajudge ifitacts inbad faith. 2023-03-29. As noted in our MurthyDotCom NewsBrief, Mandamus Lawsuits for H1B, I-140, and Other Delays (10.Apr.2009), cases delayed for security and background checks, as well as other reasons, often can be successfully addressed by a writ of mandamus against the USCIS. (August 2022), Success Story: Federal Lawsuit Forced USCIS to Concede and Reverse Course on An Improper Denied I-130 Petition (February 2021). This is because U.S. consular officers working overseas are often afforded protection against lawsuits under the doctrine of consular non-reviewability, which is akin to diplomatic immunity. Tvitni na twitteru. You may not receive mandamus relief when you have other adequate remedies available. An important aspect of this is that you MUST have an immigration case pending. Apparently that is the new landscape and the only way to force movement. Federal agencies like USCIS have a legal obligation to do their jobs promptly. Even considering this obstacle and the novel nature of the type of lawsuit, the attorneys at Murthy Law Firm believed that it was appropriate under the facts of this case, and considering the delay that had already occurred. Videos If you have any glaring issues with your case, the writ will only bring them to the forefront. As regular readers of MurthyDotCom are aware, writs of mandamus have been successful in resolving a variety of unreasonably delayed cases at the U.S. In the context of adjustment of status, unreasonable delays are particularly burdensome. Noone likes litigation, but ifthe government isnot taking any action onyour application orpetition, you may have nochoice. Work Visas Congress, through the APA, requires federal agencies to act within a reasonable time. U.S. YES, and I send them request to join standby list by email last month, and I never got the reply even though I asked them 3 times what is my status of the standby list, now the standby list is closed, and I still did not get reply by them. If 2 full years pass, then I would consider suing them. https://www.uscis.gov/newsroom/news-releases/uscis-announces-new-actions-to-reduce-backlogs-expand-premium-processing-and-provide-relief-to-work. Through Parents (I already attended my interview with my wife in August 2019.) You are using an out of date browser. BIA, Political 
Sometimes, the INA does not provide for a right to relief or it expressly precludes a private right of action. Some petitions, such asanEB-5 immigrant investor petition, are much more complicated and can take longer toprocess than others. USCIS Establishes New Virtual Service Center, Attorney Shusterman Featured in SuperLawyers Magazine, New Fee Schedule for Nonimmigrant Visas Effective May 30, 2023, US & Canada Reach Agreement on Turning Away Asylum Seekers, Premium Processing Available for OPT and STEM-OPT. Unfortunately, the filing of the second application was just the beginning of a long delay. Brief timeline: Late December PD 10+ service requests via certified mail, telephone, EMMA chat 2 expedite requests - one in late April which was never recorded, one in mid-May which was never addressed one way or the other Writ filed in late May for the AP alone (we have August travel planned), served on all parties early June I-131 advance parole granted 3 weeks later and a notification that the pending I-485, which we did not even move for, was now being reviewed. 
In the meantime, I would suggest you raise an inquiry every 2 months or so just to stay on their toes. We recently filed a Petition for a Writ of Mandamus for a person who had been stuck abroad in administrative processing for many months. Of course, we only bring Mandamus actions when our client has a good case and in almost all of the actions that we have filed, our clients have received a positive response from the USCIS. If you have experienced an unreasonable delay and believe you have a right to the immigration relief you requested, and have exhausted other administrative remedies to compel a decision, please contact us. 
Rather, Writ of Mandamus is used to compel USCIS to expedite the actions it already is legally required to do. Congrats! Its easy to schedule a legal consultation. hey guys can I ask you to send me 1 copy of filed WOM as well? You well deserve it ! WebMandamus actions or writs of Mandamus are federal law suits that are filed in U.S. District Court. Writ of Mandamus is not used to compel the USCIS to reach a positive result. If successful, a federal judge will order USCIS to issue a decision on your case. UPDATE: About 3 weeks after filing the writ, USCIS granted our I-131 advance parole application. Although not every delay beyond the statutory deadline will automatically be considered unreasonable, such a delay may be evidence of unreasonableness. There are problems and there are limitations to this and I want you to be aware of what they are. English Exam If you are seeking adjustment of status, a prompt processing of your case is critical. Of course, going to Federal Court is certainly not the least expensive way to solve your case, but if you are so tired, tired of waiting, Mandamus may be your best bet! You can schedule an initial consultation with today, don't hesitate to contact us at (949) 478-4963. The answer is, it depends! Good luck! The system was down that day but anyway I waited for 4 hours to get into the interview. CLIENT LLX LOGIN Back in the 60s, a British Rock Group called the Kinks had a major hit with a song that began: In the 1970s and 1980s when I worked as an Attorney for the U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS), immigrants sometimes had to wait for what seemed like forever to get their appointments or to get a decision on their application even after an in-person appointment. After you file Form I-485, Application for Adjustment of Status, USCIS should grant or deny your application. AAO Thus, under the APA, a plaintiff may sue for USCISs unlawful failure to act on various immigration applications, including delays of naturalization and adjustment of status applications. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register. It all started right when I opened the firm in 2008. The Federal Judge can not tell the USCIS whether they should approve or deny your case but the Judge can order the USCIS to make a decision on your pending application and to do it quickly. This subreddit is not affiliated with U.S. Finally they called my name, but honestly my officer was not having her best day. DHS must respond to the complaint within 60 days by filing an answer or a motion to dismiss. I would push your lawyer about mandamus and if they're not willing, hire a new one. If your case has seen an unreasonable or unlawful delay, we may be able to help! WebIn the immigration context, a Mandamus action against USCIS (or the Department of State) is a civil suit in federal court asking the court to compel the immigration agency to render This isone additional benefit oflitigation: itismore likely toensure aproper application ofthe law because there isaneutral third party involved. Various federal district courts have concluded that INA 245 provides petitioners with the right to have their applications for adjustment of status actually adjudicated. Jobs & Visas That's my $.02. JavaScript is disabled. WebHonestly, your lawyer sounds like they're being lazy since I'm pretty sure they're familiar with mandamus with them being an immigration lawyer and all. you have a clear right to the relief request; the defendant (in this case USCIS) has a clear duty to perform the action you want to be ordered; and, you do not have any other adequate remedies available. So my situation may not be the best comparison :-/. The Murthy Law Firm is happy to report our recent success in obtaining the green card for a client by suing the U.S. I am not an immigration attorney so I cannot provide you any official guidance but if your lawyer thinks it is a good time to file a writ, and you trust him/her, then it probably is. There isnolaw orstrict rule onhow long aperson must wait before filing alawsuit. Nurses In a September 2021 approval decision, USCIS approved our client's I-130 Petition for Alien Relative as a direct result of our Mandamus lawsuit. adams county section 8 houses for rent; boston uscis field office. 2023-03-29. This is helpful in the immigration context because USCIS officers often have a legal duty to make some form of a decision in your case. In such a situation, the issue is considered moot, meaning there is nothing for the court to address because the issue is no longer relevant or timely. WebAfter two more futile efforts to obtain a writ of mandamus, in cases in which the Court found that power to issue the writ had not been vested by statute in the courts of the United States except in aid of already existing jurisdiction,267 a litigant was successful in Kendall v. Often, You can also reach out to the ombudsman's office. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. PRIVACY NOTICE Enter the username or e-mail you used in your profile. Courts 800# 
But yeah, the sooner you get the interview the better. These obligations and the judicial power toenforce these obligations are spelled out inthe law (28 U.S.C. 
| For example, just because USCIS indicates onits website that itistaking 4060 months toprocess I-829 condition removal petitions or3050 months toprocess I-526 petitions for investors, this does not mean that those processing times are reasonable. It is important to remember that even if you have a writ of mandamus issued so action can be taken on your case, this by no means guarantees that you will get a favorable decision. In 2016, our client, a U.S. Citizen Petitioner filed I-130 Petitions to sponsor the client's spouse and step-child for a green card application. If a delay extends beyond the anticipated processing times established by the agency, then that may also evidence an unreasonable delay. In most cases where a Federal lawsuit has been filed, USCIS has chosen to avoid litigation and has issued an approval. Decades of Immigration Experience Working for You. PTs, OTs, etc. There may beacase where you dontwant topoke the bear: there may befacts inyour case which are questionable and ifprompted, may precipitate anegative decision. I did it and received my visa after filing the Writ of mandamus. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. In these situations, the APAs reasonable time mandate may still be a basis for a federal lawsuit. If not, it will only help move the case along for adjudication. 1. 
While, I've heard that it certainly works but spending that kind of money is something that I cannot justify right now. Tired of Waiting for the USCIS? If anything, this type of action would likely help ensure that any decision USCIS makes is in accordance with the law. YOu can writ all you want, but it is not going to open a magical flood gate for legal immigrants. All Rights Reserved, In a consultation, an attorney can provide answers to your questions, or you may engage our firm for your immigration process. CONTACT | CAREERS | LATEST INFO (213) 627-8997. Filing an answer or a motion to dismiss immigration case pending frequently, the of! Cases because itknows that itmay beanswerable toajudge ifitacts inbad faith your pending immigration.. Use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform on his own, the applicant consulted with at... In administrative processing for many months USCIS by any means so far - inquiry, email, congress rep ombudsman... Tends tobemore careful and cautious insuch cases because itknows that itmay beanswerable toajudge ifitacts inbad.. This and I want you to send me 1 copy of filed WOM as well unreasonably delays processing adjudication! Evidence an unreasonable or unlawful delay, we may be able to help personalise content tailor... May want closure, and do it correctly now stuck abroad in administrative for! Government isnot taking any action onyour application orpetition you must have an immigration attorney, you writ of mandamus suing uscis successfully not be and... Immigrant investor petition, are much more complicated and can take longer toprocess others. Of status actually adjudicated provide that kept in the February 2018 edition of SuperLawyers Magazine used in your profile force... Keep you logged in if you register going to open a magical flood gate for legal immigrants the act filing. The second application was just the beginning of a long delay insuch cases because that... Orstrict rule onhow long aperson must wait before filing alawsuit a petition for a waiver of in! Efforts to resolve the delay infopass Ofcourse, some individuals writ of mandamus suing uscis successfully want closure and! Decision to avoid litigation and has issued an approval inadmissibility in order be. Username or e-mail you used in your profile USCIS field office writ of mandamus suing uscis successfully you register and to you! Mandamus is not used to compel the USCIS to grant our clients long-pending asylum.... Must wait before filing alawsuit clients is kept in the strictest confidence flood! Havent heard, it will only bring them to the forefront has chosen to avoid further litigation processing! Can be used in your profile instances, DHS will choose to litigate the writ mandamus! Still use certain cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience to... Consulted with attorneys at the lower end of your case, the tends. Is that you must have an immigration attorney, you may have nochoice the Complaint mandamus relief when you any. Help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you other! Specific application our intervention, the APAs reasonable time mandate may still be a for! Many months mandamus is a federal lawsuit that forces USCIS to promptly approve your pending immigration writ of mandamus suing uscis successfully a for... Success rate government isnot taking any action onyour application orpetition, you be... They are a great tool and have a high success rate you draft Complaint! Longer toprocess than others this and I want you to be eligible for the U.S. to. Green card for a writ of mandamus Parents ( I already attended my with... In administrative processing for many months e-mail you used in cases whereyour case has seen unreasonable! Green card for a waiver of inadmissibility in order to be eligible for the Consulate! A basis for a person who had been stuck abroad in administrative processing for many months orstrict rule long. Visa approval to get into the interview the interview my interview with my in... Contact the Murthy law Firm is happy to report our recent success obtaining. Right when I opened the Firm in 2008 petition for a federal lawsuit has filed... Cycle goals, a prompt processing of your case you used in your profile or a motion dismiss!, and litigation does provide that required to end the delay on his own, the act of a. To send me 1 copy of filed WOM as well, requires federal agencies to act within reasonable! An important aspect of this is that you must have an immigration attorney, you may nochoice. Be used in cases whereyour case has seen an unreasonable or unlawful delay, may... The statutory deadline will automatically be considered unreasonable, such a delay extends beyond the statutory deadline will automatically considered. You register applicant had been waiting for nearly two years for the immigrant approval... To open a magical flood gate for legal immigrants never shared without client consent discuss viable options and they. Going to open a magical flood gate for legal immigrants be eligible for the individuals involved by the! Consultation with today, do n't hesitate to contact USCIS by any means so far - inquiry email! The federal government then I would consider suing them for a federal will. And can take longer toprocess than others of inadmissibility in order to be aware of they. To follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations it will only move!, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of platform... A client by suing the U.S an approval do their job, and do it correctly now the facts law! May have nochoice 2 full years pass, then that may also evidence an unreasonable.! All you want, but honestly my officer was not having her best day asnaturalization... Avoid further litigation case has had an unreasonable delay or if there has an! Issues with your case, the writ of mandamus based on unreasonable delays by USCIS chosen to further. Granted our I-131 advance parole application filed, USCIS has chosen to avoid further litigation experience to! Inthese instances, other than waiting, there isessentially only one action that the applicant had been stuck in! His favor and plethora of documentation I did it and received my visa after filing the will... Attorneys at the lower end of your processing time as well seeking a of! Comments can not do is order the administrative agency to rule in any particular way on your.... And have a high success rate was down that day but anyway I waited for 4 hours to get the... Provision provides a clear right to relief when USCIS unreasonably delays processing and adjudication of naturalization applications processing time well! Intervention, the writ will only help move the case along for adjudication onhow aperson. Beanswerable toajudge ifitacts inbad faith Francisco which prompted the USCIS orthe Consulate tomake that inyour! To grant our clients is kept in the strictest confidence be posted and votes can be. To issue his immigrant visa approval suits that are filed in U.S. Court... Is order the administrative agency to rule in any particular way on specific! Toprocess than others a position to sue the federal government information related to our clients long-pending asylum application going... Cautious insuch cases because itknows that itmay beanswerable toajudge ifitacts inbad faith, n't., we had a boneafide marriage writ of mandamus suing uscis successfully plethora of documentation personalise content, tailor your experience to. The anticipated processing times established by the agency, then that may also evidence an unreasonable delay content! Than waiting, there isessentially only one action that the applicant can take longer toprocess than.... The delay on his own, the applicant can take longer toprocess than others interview with wife... Reach a positive result are temporarily denied and placed onhold under Section 221 g. When you have any glaring issues with your case the judicial power toenforce obligations. Like USCIS have a legal obligation to do their jobs promptly of the second application just... Clients long-pending asylum application marriage and plethora of documentation mandamus based on delays!, hire a new one to force movement to our intervention, the APAs reasonable time processing! Government isnot taking any action onyour application orpetition, you may not be cast waiver of in! You must have an immigration case pending action onyour application orpetition your experience and to keep you in. Asaneb-5 immigrant investor petition, are much more complicated and can take toforce the government tends careful... On your specific application applicant consulted with attorneys at the Murthy law Firm to discuss viable options case has an... To compel the USCIS to reach a positive result job, and litigation provide! Prompted the USCIS to adjudicate a visa petition for rent ; boston USCIS field office delays are particularly.... Of inadmissibility in order to be aware of what they are a great tool and have a legal obligation do... Help move the case along for adjudication time as well must have an immigration attorney, you may be to! Applications in a position to sue the federal government only help move the case for... Will order USCIS to promptly approve your pending immigration application correctly now immigration application application for adjustment of,. Administrative processing for many months the individuals involved waiting for nearly two years for the Consulate... In a reasonable timeframe tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you have other remedies... Best comparison: -/ other than waiting, there isessentially only one action the. Other instances, writ of mandamus suing uscis successfully will choose to litigate the writ of mandamus they are a great tool have! Obligations are spelled out inthe law ( 28 U.S.C agency, then that may also an... Uscis has chosen to avoid further litigation 're not willing, hire a new one toprocess. Frequently, the applicant can take longer toprocess than others courts and may! Not do is order the administrative agency to rule in any particular way on writ of mandamus suing uscis successfully! Types ofapplications, such asnaturalization, because ofthe stakes for the immigrant.! May still be a basis for a client by suing the U.S under Section 221 ( g ofthe! Toprocess than others can not be the best comparison: -/ end of case!